By Ryan Michaels | Editor-in-Chief, The Maine Mirror| September 22, 2026

A split-screen image questioning missing dialogue in police footage, featuring a surveillance still from the Berwick Police Department lobby alongside a body cam recording, date and time marked. Text prompts focus on accountability and transparency. This is Ai generated. Underlying video is not.

BERWICK, Maine — What began with a written complaint delivered to the Berwick Police Department on September 12, 2025 has now developed into a larger public-records question:

Does the surveillance recording ultimately provided by the Town of Berwick contain the complete recorded encounter?

That question did not arise from speculation.

It arose after I finally accessed the Town-provided recording on September 22, 2026, compared it with my own contemporaneous recording of the encounter, and identified portions of dialogue present on my recording that do not appear in the version provided by the Town—even though dialogue immediately before and after those portions remains.

The Maine Mirror is publishing the underlying records and a direct video comparison with this article so readers can examine the evidence themselves.

This article does not conclude that anyone intentionally altered the recording. The available evidence does not yet establish why the apparent discrepancy exists, whether it resulted from export, conversion, redaction, technical processing, editing, or some other cause.

Those are now factual questions for the Town.

What the existing record does establish is a chronology stretching from the original encounter, through Police Chief Timothy Towne’s written determination that complaints concerning then-Administrative Assistant Denise Dunn were “unfounded,” through repeated efforts to obtain and inspect the surveillance footage, and finally to the September 22 discovery that the copy provided by the Town does not contain dialogue captured by my contemporaneous recording during the same lobby interaction.

September 12, 2025: The Encounter

On September 12, 2025, I entered the Berwick Police Department carrying paperwork I intended to submit.

Denise Dunn was then the Department’s administrative assistant.

My own recording captured the interaction.

I asked whether an officer was available. Dunn asked what the matter concerned. After I questioned why that information was necessary and again requested an officer, Dunn told me there was nobody there to speak with.

I then asked whether she would sign for the paperwork.

She declined.

The conversation developed into a disagreement over how I was expected to submit complaints and whether I was required to go through the Town Manager.

According to my contemporaneous recording, Dunn told me, in part, that I had “made a complaint about everybody here at the PD.”

The recording then captures a portion of the exchange that would become important more than a year later.

I began responding that because I had complained about Department personnel, “you guys are going to—”

Dunn interjected.

My recording captures Dunn saying, “you are not listening,” followed by an exchange in which she said I talked over her when she tried to tell me something.

I responded that other recordings showed her talking over me and said:

“We’ll let the footage be the proof.”

Dunn responded that she was not yelling.

I then ended the argument and walked away from the counter.

My recording continued.

It captures my reaction after observing Dunn throw the paperwork onto the floor. I returned to the window and asked whether she had thrown it, slid the paperwork back toward her, and said I would document what had occurred.

(Color-coded transcript comparing the September 12, 2025 Berwick Police Department lobby encounter as captured by the Town-provided surveillance recording and Michaels’ contemporaneous recording. Green identifies dialogue present in the BPD-produced recording. Yellow identifies dialogue occurring during the lobby interaction that is captured by Michaels’ contemporaneous recording but does not appear in the Town-provided recording. Pink identifies Michaels’ statements after walking away from the lobby interaction and is deliberately not presented as missing BPD footage.)

Color-coded transcript comparing dialogue in Berwick Police surveillance footage with a contemporaneous recording of the September 12, 2025 lobby encounter.

That last distinction is important.

The portions recorded after I walked away from the lobby interaction are not being presented as missing material from the Police Department surveillance recording.

The discrepancy concerns dialogue occurring during the lobby interaction itself, where my contemporaneous recording contains an exchange that does not appear in the Town-provided version while surrounding portions of the same conversation remain.

Watch the Recordings Yourself

The Maine Mirror has also prepared a direct video comparison.

The first clip presents the surveillance recording provided by the Town of Berwick. The second presents my contemporaneous, body-worn recording of the same encounter.

The comparison identifies the point at which dialogue captured by my recording does not appear in the Town-provided recording. It also separately identifies the later portion of my recording after I walked away so viewers can distinguish that expected difference from the internal discrepancy at issue.

No conclusion is presented in the video about why the difference exists.

Readers can watch and listen to both recordings and make the factual comparison themselves.

(Direct comparison of two recordings of the September 12, 2025 Berwick Police Department lobby encounter. The video first plays the surveillance recording provided by the Town of Berwick, followed by Michaels’ contemporaneous body-worn recording of the same encounter. On-screen markers identify dialogue occurring during the lobby interaction that is captured by Michaels’ recording but does not appear in the Town-provided recording. The video separately identifies material recorded after Michaels walked away and does not characterize that later material as missing surveillance footage. Embed the YouTube video here.)

A Formal Complaint and an Early Request for the Surveillance Footage

Two days later, on September 14, 2025, I documented the incident in writing and requested the Police Department’s lobby surveillance footage.

The correspondence specifically alleged that Dunn had thrown or pushed the paperwork onto the floor and requested the surveillance recording covering approximately 3:50 p.m. to 4:15 p.m.

The correspondence also sought an investigation and requested Dunn’s resignation.

(September 2025 formal complaint, Freedom of Access Act request and follow-up correspondence concerning the September 12 encounter. The record begins with Michaels’ September 14 complaint concerning Denise Dunn, requests her resignation, and requests Berwick Police Department lobby surveillance footage covering the period surrounding the encounter. The subsequent pages document follow-up correspondence with Town officials concerning the complaint and records request.)

The record shows that then-Town Manager Arthur Capello acknowledged receiving the September 14 email that same day.

Follow-up correspondence continued after that acknowledgment.

The chronology establishes an important point: the surveillance footage was requested almost immediately after the encounter. The recording did not become an issue only after the present discrepancy was discovered.

September 23, 2025: Chief Towne Finds the Complaints “Unfounded”

Nine days after my written complaint, Chief Timothy Towne issued a letter.

Towne wrote that he had received my complaints concerning Dunn and had investigated them.

After addressing a separate complaint concerning Dunn’s access to material associated with an earlier police report, Towne turned specifically to September 12:

“I also investigated your allegations that she threw your written complaint onto the floor on September 12th, 2025.”

His conclusion immediately followed:

“I have found both of your complaints to be unfounded.”

Towne further wrote that, in an effort to make me “feel more comfortable,” Dunn would make arrangements for a duty officer or staff member to speak with me if I came to the station.

(September 23, 2025 letter from Berwick Police Chief Timothy Towne responding to Michaels’ complaints concerning then-Administrative Assistant Denise Dunn. Towne states that he investigated Michaels’ allegation that Dunn threw his written complaint onto the floor on September 12, 2025 and concludes, “I have found both of your complaints to be unfounded.” The letter also describes arrangements for a duty officer or staff member to speak with Michaels during future visits to the station.)

That finding is now especially relevant.

There was a Police Department surveillance system. There was my contemporaneous recording. There was a written complaint requesting the surveillance footage within days of the incident. And there was a formal finding from the Police Chief stating that he had investigated the allegation and found the complaints unfounded.

The newly identified discrepancy therefore raises another factual question:

What evidence did Chief Towne review before reaching that conclusion, and did that evidence include the original September 12 surveillance recording?

The records currently available for this article do not answer that question.

Denise Dunn and the Current Administrative Assistant Are Different People

One distinction is essential to the remainder of this chronology.

Denise Dunn is not the administrative assistant involved in the September 2026 events described below.

Dunn was the administrative assistant involved in the September 12, 2025 encounter.

My September 14 correspondence requested her resignation. The records published with this article document that request.

Dunn later left the position. By September 2026, another employee was serving as the Police Department’s administrative assistant.

The records presently included with this article establish the resignation request, but they do not establish that my request caused Dunn’s subsequent departure. No such causal claim is being made here.

Accordingly, every reference below to the current administrative assistant or Police Department administrative assistant concerns a different employee—not Denise Dunn.

That distinction matters both for accuracy and fairness.

The Effort to Obtain an Accessible Recording Continues

The surveillance footage remained an issue into 2026.

The dispute eventually narrowed to something straightforward: I wanted to inspect the identified recording and confirm that the footage was actually accessible before leaving with another copy.

Maine’s Freedom of Access Act generally provides a right to inspect public records during reasonable office hours, subject to statutory exceptions and scheduling provisions. For electronically stored public records, the law also addresses the form in which access is provided. (Maine State Legislature)

My request did not depend upon being given access to a Police Department computer.

The correspondence repeatedly said so.

September 2026: Town Counsel Becomes Involved

By September 2026, Town attorney Matt Tarasevich was corresponding about the recording.

On September 11, Tarasevich wrote that a disc containing the requested information was at the Police Department, had been tested and was operational, and remained available for pickup. He also stated that neither Towne nor another Town official would meet with me to “review or test” the disc.

I responded that this was not what I had requested.

I was not asking Towne to interpret the recording, discuss its contents, conduct an evidentiary review, or sit through it with me.

I was asking to inspect the public record and verify that the replacement copy was accessible before leaving with it.

The correspondence continued.

(Full September 2026 correspondence chain documenting the development of the Berwick surveillance-recording dispute. The record includes Town counsel’s statement that a tested and operational disc was available; Michaels’ repeated distinction between inspecting the public record and asking Town personnel to review or interpret it with him; the September 21 notice concerning the following day’s unrelated Police Department visit; and the September 22 factual update after the recording was finally accessed and compared with Michaels’ contemporaneous recording.)

The larger email chain contains other matters, including questions previously directed to the Berwick Select Board concerning Chief Towne’s proposed dual role as Police Chief and a candidate for the Maine House.

Those issues are not the focus of this article.

For this chronology, the relevant portion is the public-record dispute that became intertwined with that correspondence and my documented effort to keep the matters separate.

September 16: A Library Becomes Part of the Story

A September 16 interaction added another unusual element.

During a telephone conversation concerning an unrelated inquiry, the current Police Department administrative assistant raised the recording.

According to my subsequent written account to Town counsel, she told me that the disc was available for pickup and that, because Department computers could not be used for that purpose, she had taken the recording to the Berwick Public Library, played it on a library computer, watched it and confirmed that it worked.

Again, this employee was not Denise Dunn.

I told her that I was waiting for Town counsel to answer the inspection issue and did not want to resolve that disagreement with her personally.

The library information nevertheless established something practical: the disc apparently could be accessed using a computer outside the Police Department.

September 21: One Last Attempt to Remove the Ambiguity

On September 21, I sent counsel another detailed written clarification.

I stated that the question was now simply whether the Town would permit me to inspect the recording.

I expressly said I was not insisting on a Police Department computer, was not requiring Towne to attend, was not asking anyone to watch or interpret the recording with me, was not asking anyone to test it for me, and was not asking the Town to create a new record.

The email also addressed something expected to happen the following day.

I anticipated visiting the Police Department on September 22 for an unrelated matter.

I therefore wrote in advance:

“I will not be asking the administrative assistant about this recording, attempting to pick it up, or seeking to resolve my outstanding inspection request with her during that visit.”

I asked that the unrelated visit remain separate from the recording dispute and that communications concerning the recording continue through the existing correspondence with counsel.

(Complete September 21, 2026 email from Michaels to Town counsel clarifying the outstanding inspection request. The correspondence distinguishes inspection from asking Town personnel to review or test the recording, documents previous accessibility problems and the administrative assistant’s reported library viewing, and expressly states that Michaels’ anticipated September 22 Police Department visit concerned an unrelated matter and would not be used to ask the administrative assistant about the recording, pick it up, or resolve the inspection dispute with her.)

(Screenshot of the “Tomorrow’s Unrelated Visit” section of Michaels’ September 21, 2026 correspondence to Town counsel. The excerpt documents in advance that Michaels expected to visit the Berwick Police Department the following day regarding an unrelated matter; would not ask the administrative assistant about the recording, attempt to pick it up, or seek to resolve the outstanding inspection request with her; and requested that communications concerning the recording remain within the existing correspondence with Town counsel.)

A typed letter outlining the author's intention to visit the Berwick Police Department regarding an unrelated matter, emphasizing the need to keep this visit separate from ongoing correspondence concerning an inspection request.

That advance notice became important less than 24 hours later.

September 22: The Recording Is Introduced Anyway

I went to the Berwick Police Department on September 22 concerning the separate matter I had described in advance.

I did not go there to obtain the surveillance recording.

I did not ask the current administrative assistant for it.

I did not attempt to resolve the inspection dispute with her.

While I was speaking with the responding officer, however, the current administrative assistant—not Denise Dunn—brought the disc into the interaction and provided it to the officer to give to me.

The distinction bears repeating because these are two different employees separated by roughly a year.

I explained the history of the inspection issue to the officer and made clear that I was not demanding use of a Police Department computer. I simply wanted to verify that the responsive recording could actually be accessed.

The officer asked whether the library was open.

He then offered to accompany me there.

I followed him to the Berwick Public Library.

At the library, I was finally able to access the disc and verify that it contained playable video.

After more than a year of attempting to obtain and successfully access the recording, that resolved the practical inspection problem.

And that part of the story deserves to be documented clearly:

The responding officer helped resolve it.

But something else happened during that interaction.

“Directed Not to View the Recording”

During the September 22 interaction, the responding officer stated on multiple occasions that he had been directed not to view the recording.

I recorded the interaction.

At this stage, The Maine Mirror is not attributing that instruction to any particular person because the evidence currently available does not establish who issued it.

Nor does the statement, standing alone, establish why the instruction was given.

There may be an ordinary explanation.

But given the history of the recording and what I discovered later that day, the instruction is relevant enough that its source and purpose should be established through records rather than speculation.

Then I Compared the Recordings

After returning home, I compared the Town-provided recording with my own contemporaneous September 12, 2025 recording.

That is when the issue changed.

The recordings do not merely have different beginning or ending points.

Instead, my contemporaneous recording contains dialogue occurring within the encounter that does not appear in the Town-provided version, while surrounding portions of the conversation remain.

The disputed section begins as I was responding to Dunn’s statement that I had complained about Department personnel.

My contemporaneous recording captures the subsequent exchange:

Dunn: “You are not listening.”
Michaels: “I am listening to you.”
Dunn: “You talk over me every time I try to tell you something.”
Michaels: “Every other recording shows you talking over me and yelling like you just did. We’ll let the footage be the proof.”
Dunn: “I’m not yelling.”

The Town-provided recording then contains subsequent dialogue from the encounter.

That distinction is critical.

If one recording simply began later or ended earlier than another, differing recording durations could provide an obvious explanation.

Here, the identified difference occurs inside an otherwise continuing lobby conversation.

That does not establish intentional editing.

It does establish a question that can be answered objectively:

Is the recording provided by the Town a complete reproduction of the responsive surveillance recording as originally maintained by the Berwick Police Department?

The Town Was Immediately Asked That Question

At 5:59 p.m. on September 22, I sent a factual update to Town counsel and municipal officials documenting what had occurred.

I acknowledged that the officer’s assistance at the library had resolved the practical inspection problem and expressed appreciation for his help.

I documented his statement that he had been directed not to view the recording.

I also documented the discrepancy discovered after comparing the Town-provided recording with my contemporaneous recording.

The email deliberately avoided alleging a cause.

I wrote:

“I am not presently alleging why those discrepancies exist, who caused them, or whether they resulted from intentional editing, redaction, export, technical processing, or some other circumstance.”

I then asked the Town one factual question:

“Does the Town represent that the recording provided to me today is a complete reproduction of the responsive September 12, 2025 surveillance recording as originally maintained by the Berwick Police Department, with no responsive audio or video removed, redacted, muted, clipped, withheld, or otherwise excluded?”

The September 22 update appears in the larger correspondence record included with this article.

That question is central because it does not require anyone to accept my interpretation of the underlying confrontation.

Either the produced file completely reproduces the responsive source recording, or it does not.

If it does not, the next questions concern what was excluded, through what process and why.

A Preservation Notice Follows

Minutes later, at 6:03 p.m., I sent a separate preservation notice.

The notice requested preservation of the original/native September 12 surveillance recording; copies, exports and derivative versions; available metadata; audit, access, export and system logs; records documenting creation and processing of the disc; records concerning any clipping, trimming, muting, removal, withholding or conversion; records concerning the library testing; records concerning Towne’s 2025 investigation; and records concerning any instruction that a Department employee or officer not view, review or access the recording.

(September 22, 2026 preservation notice issued after Michaels compared his contemporaneous recording with the Town-provided surveillance recording. The notice requests preservation of the original/native September 12, 2025 surveillance recording; all existing copies, exports and derivative versions; available metadata and system logs; records concerning creation, processing and testing of the disc; records concerning any editing, clipping, trimming, redaction, muting, removal, withholding, conversion or other processing; records concerning Chief Towne’s 2025 investigation and evidence considered; and records concerning any instruction that a Berwick Police Department employee or officer not view, review or access the recording.)

The preservation notice again expressly avoided alleging why the discrepancies exist.

Its purpose was simpler: preserve the evidence while the underlying questions are addressed.

A New Public-Records Request Seeks the Provenance

I also submitted a new Freedom of Access Act request seeking records capable of establishing the provenance, preservation, processing and production of the recording.

That request seeks, among other things, the original/native recording and existing versions; available metadata and system information; records concerning the creation, preparation, copying, export, testing or processing of the disc; records concerning Towne’s September 2025 investigation and evidence reviewed; records concerning the instruction that the responding officer not view the recording; and applicable policies and retention information.

Under Maine law, an agency or official generally must acknowledge receipt of a sufficiently described public-records request within five working days. A denial must be provided in writing and state the reason, and current law requires the written denial to cite the statutory authority relied upon. (Maine State Legislature)

(SEPTEMBER 22, 2026 FOAA REQUEST PDF | The request seeks records concerning the original/native September 12, 2025 surveillance recording and existing versions; metadata and available system or access information; creation, export, testing and production of the disc; Chief Towne’s 2025 investigation and evidence reviewed; the instruction that the September 22 responding officer not view the recording; and applicable surveillance, retention, public-record processing and complaint-investigation policies.)

What Is Established—and What Is Not

There is enough documentation to separate established facts from unanswered questions.

The record establishes that I complained about Dunn’s September 12, 2025 conduct within days of the encounter and requested the lobby surveillance footage.

It establishes that Chief Towne subsequently wrote that he investigated the allegation that Dunn threw my written complaint onto the floor and found both complaints “unfounded.”

It establishes a lengthy subsequent effort to obtain and successfully access the recording.

It establishes that immediately before the September 22, 2026 visit, I expressly told Town counsel in writing that I was going to the Police Department for an unrelated matter and would not attempt to obtain or resolve the recording issue with the administrative assistant.

According to my contemporaneous documentation of the following day’s events, the current administrative assistant nonetheless introduced the disc into my interaction with the responding officer.

The officer helped me access it at the library.

According to my recording of that interaction, the officer also stated that he had been directed not to view the recording.

And the two recordings themselves can now be compared directly.

What the presently available evidence does not establish is why the identified dialogue is absent from the Town-provided recording.

It does not establish who, if anyone, removed material.

It does not establish whether the difference resulted from intentional editing, a redaction process, an export setting, conversion, a technical issue or another cause.

It does not establish who instructed the September 22 officer not to view the recording or why.

And it does not yet establish what evidence Chief Towne reviewed before reaching his September 23, 2025 “unfounded” determination.

Those questions require records and evidence.

Why the Original Recording Matters Now

The most important evidence is no longer another email explaining anyone’s position.

It is the source record.

If the Police Department still possesses the original/native surveillance file, comparing that file with the copy provided to me could establish whether the identified discrepancy exists in the source recording or arose somewhere in the process of exporting, copying, converting, redacting or otherwise producing the version ultimately provided.

Associated metadata, export records or system logs—if they exist and have been retained—could provide additional information.

That is why the preservation notice matters.

It is also why the chronology matters.

The surveillance footage was requested shortly after the September 12, 2025 encounter.

Chief Towne subsequently issued an investigative conclusion concerning that encounter.

The recording remained the subject of documented access efforts.

Town counsel later became involved.

The current administrative assistant reported having successfully accessed the disc at the library.

A responding officer ultimately helped me do the same.

And only after finally viewing the produced recording was I able to conduct the comparison that generated the present questions.

The Question Is Now Narrower Than Ever

After more than a year, the central question can now be stated without rhetoric:

Is the September 12, 2025 recording provided by the Town of Berwick a complete reproduction of the responsive surveillance recording originally maintained by the Berwick Police Department?

If it is, the Town can say so, and the underlying source records may help explain why the two recordings differ.

If it is not, the next questions are what was excluded, when, through what process, and on what basis.

Separately, records can establish what evidence Chief Towne reviewed before finding the September 12 complaint “unfounded.”

Records may also establish who directed the September 22 officer not to view the recording and why.

None of those questions requires assumptions about anyone’s motives.

They require evidence.

The preservation notice has been sent.

The public-records request has been submitted.

And now the public can watch the recordings for itself.

The Maine Mirror will update this reporting as responsive records and substantive answers are received.


Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One Response

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading