After identifying his own correspondence as the only responsive record in a November 16 disclosure, Maine DHHS now faces questions about its handling of an earlier records request, including a documented discrepancy between the dates requested and the dates the Department recorded.

By Ryan Michaels | Founder & Editor-in-Chief, The Maine Mirror

Graphic about Maine DHHS FOAA discrepancies, showing two records requests with different responses and a magnifying glass.

November 17, 2026

A New Development in an Ongoing Accountability Dispute

On October 28, 2026, The Maine Mirror reported that an account bearing the name of Maine Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) employee Amy Cilley had appeared in my TikTok profile-view history.

The discovery prompted two separate actions: a written request for an explanation from leadership at Maine’s Office of Child and Family Services (OCFS), and a formal Freedom of Access Act (FOAA) request seeking existing records concerning the activity.

Readers can review the original reporting, including the documented discovery and correspondence with OCFS leadership, here:

Previous Reporting: Maine DHHS, Amy Cilley, TikTok Profile Views, and the OCFS Complaint — October 28, 2026

On November 16, DHHS formally closed that records request, assigned FOAA #2338.

The Department identified just one responsive record.

It was my own email to OCFS leadership.

That determination has prompted additional questions, not only about the Department’s handling of the October incident, but also about its handling of an earlier records request concerning DHHS personnel viewing my public advocacy.

A review of the earlier correspondence reveals a separate, documented discrepancy: DHHS twice identified a narrower timeframe than the one expressly stated in my original January 17 request.

I have now sought clarification from the Department.

October 28: The Discovery and the Formal Records Request

The events began on October 28, when the TikTok account @amycilley appeared in my profile-view history.

Amy Cilley is a named defendant in my pending federal civil-rights lawsuit, Michaels v. Haynes et al., Case No. 2:26-cv-00056-LEW.

She had also previously made recorded statements to law enforcement concerning my social-media activity on March 11, 2025, in connection with events involving a no-trespass restriction.

These circumstances made the appearance of the account particularly relevant to my ongoing efforts to document interactions with DHHS personnel.

Importantly, a TikTok profile-view notification does not independently establish who physically accessed the account, why the profile was viewed, or whether any activity was connected to government business.

Those questions remain unresolved.

Rather than assume the purpose of the activity, I submitted a formal records request to DHHS at approximately 1:04 p.m. on October 28.

The request sought existing records for October 21–28, 2026, including communications, screenshots, memoranda, instructions, and other documentation concerning Cilley’s possible review of my public social-media activity.

It also sought records concerning any agency purpose, supervisory involvement, or coordination associated with the activity.

Given the pending federal litigation, the request included a formal notice asking the Department to preserve potentially relevant records.

The following two images document the original request and the screenshot accompanying it.

(Screenshot of the October 28, 2026 formal Maine FOAA request concerning Amy Cilley’s reported social-media activity, submitted at approximately 1:04 p.m. The highlighted subject line identifies the request, while the body specifies five categories of records sought for October 21–28, 2026, and includes a formal preservation notice.)

The October 28 records request sought communications, screenshots, instructions, and other existing records concerning the reported social-media activity.

(Continuation of the October 28 FOAA request, displayed directly above the accompanying TikTok screenshot showing the account username @amycilley in the profile-view history. This image documents the account appearance underlying the request but does not independently establish who operated the account or why the profile was viewed.)

The screenshot accompanying the records request shows the account username @amycilley in TikTok's profile-view history. It does not independently establish who accessed the account.

OCFS Leadership Was Also Asked for an Explanation

Separately, I contacted OCFS leadership that afternoon.

My October 28 email was addressed to Bobbi Johnson, with John Feeney, Jenny Hinson, and Lindsay Hammes copied.

The subject was:

“Amy Cilley — October 28, 2026 — Request for Explanation.”

In that correspondence, I documented the TikTok account’s appearance and requested a substantive written response addressing whether the activity was authorized, conducted in connection with official duties, or otherwise known to the Department.

I also asked who would be responsible for reviewing the concern and when I could expect a response.

These were questions directed to agency leadership, distinct from my request for existing public records.

(Copy of the October 28, 2026 email to OCFS leadership, addressed to Bobbi Johnson and copied to John Feeney, Jenny Hinson, and Lindsay Hammes. The correspondence requests clarification regarding whether the reported social-media activity was authorized, connected to official duties, or known to DHHS, and asks who will review the concern.)

Michaels separately asked OCFS leadership whether the reported activity was authorized, connected to official duties, or known to the Department.

November 16: DHHS Identifies One Responsive Record

On November 16, DHHS Public Access Officer Khristin Levey issued the Department’s closure determination for FOAA #2338.

The response stated:

“Please note the only responsive records for this request is the email sent by the requester sent to Bobb Johnson, John Feeney, Jenny Hinson, and Lindsay Hammes.”

The Department further stated that processing required two hours or less, generated no time-cost estimate, and that the request was considered closed.

In other words, the only record DHHS identified for production was correspondence I had already sent to its leadership.

The response did not identify additional internal communications, instructions, screenshots, or agency records concerning the activity.

That does not necessarily establish that such records exist or that the Department failed to locate records it was legally required to produce.

However, the determination raises questions about what records were searched and how DHHS decided which correspondence was responsive.

It also provides a new point of comparison with an earlier FOAA request.

(Excerpt from the November 16, 2026 closure letter for FOAA #2338, signed by DHHS Public Access Officer Khristin Levey. The letter identifies Michaels’s own October 28 email to OCFS leadership as the only responsive record and states that the request was completed in two hours or less.)

DHHS closed FOAA #2338 on November 16, stating that the only responsive record was correspondence Michaels had sent to OCFS leadership.

The Earlier Request: FOAA #1681

On January 17, 2026, I submitted another records request concerning DHHS personnel reviewing my public social-media advocacy.

That request followed reported Facebook profile-view activity involving DHHS employees Chelcie Stewart and Leesa Marie on January 14 and 15.

It was subsequently assigned FOAA #1681.

My original request expressly stated:

“I request all records created, accessed, or maintained on or after January 12, 2026.”

The request included internal communications referencing my social-media activity, public advocacy, complaints, administrative appeal, and related proceedings.

Among the recipients copied on my January 17 correspondence were Lindsay Hammes, Bobbi Johnson, and Khristin Levey.

These names are relevant because some of the same officials were involved in the October correspondence that DHHS subsequently identified as responsive under #2338.

Yet when DHHS closed #1681 on January 29, it did not similarly identify my original January 17 correspondence as a responsive record.

There may be a distinction between the two requests. The January 17 email was itself a FOAA submission, whereas the October 28 email to OCFS leadership was a separate request for an explanation.

Whether that distinction accounts for the Department’s different treatment is a question I have now put directly to DHHS.

The more consequential issue, however, concerns the timeframe of FOAA #1681.

January 12 Onward Became January 14–15

The January 17 request did not limit the records sought to the two dates on which I had documented the reported Facebook activity.

It requested records on or after January 12, 2026.

Nevertheless, DHHS’s January 20 acknowledgment identified the requested timeframe as January 14–15.

When the Department closed the request on January 29, it repeated that same narrower timeframe.

That creates a discrepancy across three documents:

I did not request or authorize a limitation to those two dates.

The correspondence establishes that the Department recorded a narrower timeframe twice. It does not, by itself, establish that the actual records search was limited to those dates.

That distinction is important.

If DHHS searched the full requested period but inaccurately described the timeframe, the administrative record requires clarification.

If the Department actually limited its search to January 14–15 without addressing the remainder of the request, the issue becomes whether FOAA #1681 was fulfilled in its entirety.

Either way, the discrepancy deserves a direct answer.

September 21: DHHS Asked What Assistance I Needed

This matter had not simply disappeared from my correspondence.

On September 5, I replied to the original January 17 email thread seeking assistance.

On September 21, DHHS responded:

“FOAA #1681 was closed on 1/29/26, attached is the closing letter that was sent to you. Can you please clarify what you are seeking assistance with?”

The November 16 closure of #2338 prompted me to revisit that exchange and examine the Department’s earlier handling of #1681 more closely.

On November 17, I replied to the September correspondence, identifying the date-range discrepancy and asking DHHS to explain it.

Specifically, I requested confirmation of whether the actual search covered January 12 onward or was restricted to January 14–15.

I also asked whether the Department possessed any correspondence documenting my agreement to narrow the request, what steps would be taken if the original scope had not been searched, and why the narrower dates appeared in both the acknowledgment and closure if the full period had been covered.

(Screenshot of Ryan Michaels’s November 17, 2026 follow-up email in the FOAA #1681 correspondence thread. The email responds to DHHS’s September 21 request for clarification, identifies the discrepancy between the January 12 onward timeframe originally requested and the January 14–15 timeframe recorded by DHHS, and asks four specific questions about the scope and completeness of the Department’s search.)

Michaels requested clarification on whether DHHS searched the full period originally requested under FOAA #1681.

Two Requests, Two Questions Requiring Answers

The developments now present two distinct issues.

The first concerns how DHHS determines which correspondence is responsive.

Under FOAA #2338, the Department identified my own October 28 email to leadership as the only responsive record.

Under FOAA #1681, my January 17 correspondence was not similarly identified.

The requests differed, and that difference may explain the treatment. I have asked the Department to clarify its reasoning rather than assume an improper motive.

The second concerns whether DHHS processed the full timeframe requested under #1681.

That question arises directly from the Department’s written acknowledgment and closure, both of which identified January 14–15 despite the original request seeking records from January 12 onward.

The two issues should not be confused.

One concerns the Department’s responsiveness determination.

The other concerns the scope of its records search.

Both can be addressed through specific explanations grounded in the existing administrative record.

What the Records Establish—and What They Do Not

The documentation presently establishes that an account bearing Amy Cilley’s name appeared in my TikTok profile-view history; that I formally notified OCFS leadership and submitted a records request; and that DHHS closed #2338 by identifying my own correspondence as the only responsive record.

It also establishes that DHHS twice recorded a narrower timeframe for #1681 than the timeframe expressly stated in my original request.

These documents do not establish that DHHS employees unlawfully monitored my social media, that records were deliberately withheld, or that the Department intentionally narrowed a search.

Those conclusions would require additional evidence.

What the records do establish is that specific questions about the Department’s handling of these requests remain open.

A closed FOAA request is an administrative determination. It is not necessarily an answer to every substantive question raised by the underlying events.

Similarly, the absence of additional responsive records does not, by itself, establish whether OCFS leadership investigated the concern or reached a conclusion about the reported activity.

The Next Step Is a Written Explanation

The Department now has an opportunity to explain its differing treatment of correspondence and clarify whether #1681 was searched according to the timeframe originally requested.

I am not asking DHHS to create records that do not exist.

I am asking it to explain its own documented decisions.

Government transparency depends not only on whether records are released, but also on whether public institutions accurately process the requests submitted to them and can explain the scope of their determinations.

The relevant correspondence is now documented.

The discrepancies have been identified.

And the questions have been submitted directly to the Department.

As documented in The Maine Mirror’s original October 28 reporting, this matter began with a request for an explanation of a specific, documented event.

It has since expanded into questions about the Department’s handling of two public-records requests.

The next development will be whether DHHS provides a substantive explanation—and what that explanation reveals about the completeness of these two records requests.

As of publication on November 17, 2026, the Department’s responses to these latest clarification requests have not been established in the materials reviewed for this article. The Maine Mirror will report further developments as they become available.


Support Independent Journalism

The Maine Mirror is committed to Truth | Transparency | Accountability through evidence-based reporting, original documentation, and scrutiny of public institutions.

If you believe public institutions should be able to explain their decisions, support independent journalism by subscribing below for free.

Your support helps ensure that documented questions remain part of the public record.

Editorial Disclosure: Ryan Michaels is the founder and editor-in-chief of The Maine Mirror and a named plaintiff in the federal litigation discussed in this article. This reporting concerns events in which he is personally involved and is based on his correspondence, screenshots, and DHHS records.


Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading