Two virtually identical records requests. A $50,875 processing estimate. A subsequent confidentiality denial. And a government official whose involvement raises serious questions about whether the Department’s alternative records-access process is meaningfully accessible.

Maine DHHS document showing $50,875 with a red denied stamp

By Ryan Michaels | Founder and Editor-in-Chief, The Maine Mirror

November 13, 2026


Editor’s Disclosure: In the interest of full transparency, I am both the journalist reporting this story and the disabled veteran directly involved in the circumstances described. As the founder and Editor-in-Chief of The Maine Mirror, I recognize the importance of distinguishing my personal experiences from independently verifiable facts. This article draws upon official government correspondence, documented interactions, and supporting evidence made available for public examination. My personal involvement is disclosed openly so readers can evaluate the record, the questions raised, and the Department’s responses for themselves. My commitment remains the same: Truth. Transparency. Accountability.


What happens when you follow the government’s instructions, only to find yourself right back where you started?

For more than a year, I have been attempting to obtain records from the Maine Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) and its Office of Child and Family Services (OCFS) concerning myself, my family, and the Department’s handling of matters involving us.

I have submitted formal Freedom of Access Act (FOAA) requests, communicated with the Department’s Public Access Officer, documented telephone calls, left voicemail messages, and visited DHHS offices in person.

The latest developments bring two longstanding concerns together in a way that I believe warrants public scrutiny.

In August 2025, DHHS estimated that reviewing records responsive to my request would cost $50,875, involve approximately 2,037 hours of work, and take nine to twelve months.

In November 2026, the same Department denied a subsequent request seeking virtually identical records, citing statutory confidentiality.

And when I attempted to pursue the alternative records-review process DHHS described, the Department directed me to Nathaniel “Nate” Oliver, an OCFS Program Administrator whom I have documented attempting to reach since February 2025.

On November 12, 2026, I went to the Sanford DHHS office seeking assistance.

On November 13, I followed the Department’s instructions again and called Oliver directly.

I reached his voicemail.

The significance of these events is not simply that I have been unable to obtain the records I requested.

It is that the Department’s own correspondence raises questions about how it has handled two materially identical requests—and whether the alternative process it offers is actually accessible to someone who has repeatedly sought assistance through that very process.

A $50,875 Estimate to Review Government Records

On August 27, 2025, DHHS issued an official response to FOAA request #1401.

The request sought records pertaining to me, including internal communications, case-related documentation, references to my public advocacy, social media material, metadata, and records involving identified DHHS and OCFS personnel.

The Department provided a preliminary, nonbinding estimate of the work required to retrieve, compile, and review potentially responsive records.

Its estimate was extraordinary.

$50,875 for 2,037 hours of work, with an anticipated processing period of nine to twelve months after payment.

This was not an amount DHHS claimed I owed for records already produced. It was the estimated cost of processing the request.

The Department further stated that it would not proceed without payment and that the estimate could increase depending on the actual volume of responsive documents.

(Excerpt from DHHS’s August 27, 2025 FOAA #1401 response, documenting its $50,875 estimate, 2,037 projected processing hours, anticipated nine-to-twelve-month timeframe, and payment requirements.)

Maine DHHS official letter dated August 27, 2025, reproducing Ryan Michaels’ Freedom of Access Act request #1401 for records involving himself, his family, OCFS communications, case documentation, and government personnel.
Maine DHHS August 27, 2025 FOAA #1401 response estimating $50,875 and 2,037 hours to review requested records, with an anticipated processing time of nine to twelve months after payment.

The accompanying invoice reinforced the scale of the demand.

It identified FOAA #1401 and listed the total as $50,875.

(Official Maine DHHS invoice excerpt identifying FOAA request #1401 and the total estimated processing charge of $50,875.)

Official Maine DHHS invoice #1401 showing a total estimated charge of $50,875 for processing a Freedom of Access Act records request, with payment instructions to the Treasurer, State of Maine.

But the amount alone is not the most important part of this story.

What matters is how DHHS described the work it intended to perform—and what it said about confidential records.

DHHS Acknowledged Confidentiality in 2025

On October 3, 2025, DHHS Public Access Officer Khristin Levey provided additional clarification concerning FOAA #1401.

The Department stated that it had identified approximately 15,282 emails potentially responsive to my inquiry.

Based on that volume, DHHS estimated approximately 2,037 hours of review and redaction work.

The Department also explained that the estimate reflected a comprehensive search for potentially responsive public records under Maine’s Freedom of Access Act.

Most importantly, it expressly addressed confidentiality.

DHHS stated that if a record, or any portion of a record, was determined to be confidential under applicable law, the Department would identify the relevant statute and provide guidance concerning access to nonconfidential portions.

That is an important distinction.

The Department was not claiming that every potentially responsive record was automatically subject to public disclosure.

It recognized that confidentiality restrictions might apply and described a process for evaluating those restrictions during review.

(October 3, 2025 official DHHS correspondence identifying approximately 15,282 potentially responsive emails, 2,037 estimated processing hours, and the Department’s stated approach to identifying confidential material while addressing nonconfidential portions.)

Maine DHHS correspondence identifying approximately 15,282 potentially responsive emails and 2,037 estimated review hours, explaining that confidential records would be identified under applicable law and guidance provided for accessing nonconfidential portions.

The same correspondence also described a separate procedure for requesting access to certain confidential child protective records.

Under that procedure, an eligible individual could contact a district Program Administrator, request to inspect records, and potentially arrange an in-person appointment.

In other words, DHHS was already aware of the confidentiality issue in 2025.

It had expressly discussed the distinction between public records and confidential child protective records.

That makes what happened in November 2026 particularly important.

For completeness, DHHS later declared FOAA #1401 administratively abandoned in February 2026, citing the absence of a response to its inquiry about payment or narrowing the request. That administrative closure did not produce the records.

This does not resolve the question raised by its later handling of a materially identical request.

November 2026: The Same Records, a Different Response

On November 5, 2026, DHHS issued a formal denial concerning FOAA request #2159.

The Department cited 22 M.R.S. §4008, the Maine statute governing confidentiality of child protective records.

Its explanation was direct: child protective records are confidential by statute and are not subject to disclosure under FOAA.

DHHS then directed me toward a separate process for requesting an in-person review of records pertaining to me.

(Excerpt from DHHS’s November 5, 2026 FOAA #2159 denial, stating that the Department is denying the request under 22 M.R.S. §4008 because child protective records are confidential and not subject to FOAA.)

Maine DHHS November 5, 2026 FOAA #2159 denial letter citing 22 M.R.S. §4008, stating that child protective records are confidential and directing individuals seeking their own records to request an in-person review.

Here is what makes this particularly difficult to reconcile.

The underlying records-request language reproduced in DHHS’s August 27, 2025 letter and November 5, 2026 denial is virtually identical.

The documents contain minor differences in introductory language, formatting, and other details, but they seek materially the same categories of records.

The 2025 request identified the people, subjects, communications, and records I was seeking.

The 2026 request sought essentially the same information.

Yet the Department’s responses were substantially different.

In 2025, DHHS described a potentially extensive review-and-redaction process and calculated a $50,875 estimate.

In November 2026, it denied the request on confidentiality grounds and directed me elsewhere.

To be clear, those responses are not necessarily legally incompatible. An agency may identify potentially responsive records during a preliminary search and later determine that particular records are confidential.

Nor does the existence of 15,282 potentially responsive emails establish that all those emails are public records subject to disclosure.

But the difference in treatment warrants an explanation.

Did DHHS determine that every potentially responsive record was confidential?

Were any records or portions of records outside the scope of 22 M.R.S. §4008?

And what changed between the Department’s earlier explanation of its review-and-redaction process and its subsequent denial?

These are not rhetorical accusations.

They are specific questions arising from the Department’s own written correspondence.

The Department’s Proposed Solution: Contact Nathaniel Oliver

After the November 5 denial, I continued seeking clarification.

On November 6, Levey reiterated that the records were considered confidential child protective records and directed me to the Sanford OCFS Program Administrator for the alternative review process.

I subsequently requested the administrator’s name and direct contact information.

On November 12, 2026, Levey provided that information.

The administrator was Nathaniel Oliver.

(November 12, 2026 email from DHHS Public Access Officer Khristin Levey identifying Nathaniel Oliver as the Sanford OCFS Program Administrator and providing his official contact information.)

November 12, 2026 email from Maine DHHS Public Access Officer Khristin Levey identifying Nathaniel Oliver as the Sanford OCFS Program Administrator and providing his official email address and telephone number for records-review inquiries.

For someone unfamiliar with my history involving DHHS, that instruction might seem entirely reasonable.

Contact the designated administrator. Submit the appropriate request. Arrange an appointment if eligible.

But I recognized the name immediately.

Because I had already spent more than a year attempting to obtain assistance from that same individual.

A Documented History Dating Back to February 2025

My attempts to communicate with Nathaniel Oliver did not begin with FOAA #2159.

They date back to February 2025.

According to my chronological documentary record, a February 20, 2025 DHHS intake entry reflected my desire to speak with someone in authority about ongoing CPS-related concerns.

On February 25, I described being referred to Oliver by Sanford OCFS staff and being told he would return my call.

On February 26, I recorded a telephone call that reached a voicemail greeting identifying Nate Oliver as an OCFS Program Administrator.

I left my name, contact information, and a request for assistance.

On March 3, I attempted to reach him again.

The call went to voicemail.

On March 6, I made another recorded attempt, again requesting assistance or a referral to someone else who could help.

Then, on March 11, 2025, I went to the Biddeford DHHS office in person.

I repeatedly asked to speak with Oliver.

I explained that I was willing to wait or arrange an appointment if he was unavailable.

During that interaction, DHHS employee Jean Haynes acknowledged that I was seeking to meet with Oliver.

When I asked about his availability, she stated:

“He’s not going to meet with you.”

That statement was recorded and is identified in my documentary chronology.

The chronology also identifies subsequent communications and evidence submissions involving Oliver’s name or official email address.

Those later records do not necessarily establish that Oliver personally reviewed the materials or deliberately declined to respond.

What the chronology does establish is a documented history of my attempts to obtain contact and assistance.

And it provides the context for why DHHS’s November 2026 referral raises such a serious practical concern.

(Complete chronological documentary record of Ryan Michaels’s attempts to contact Nathaniel “Nate” Oliver, including February and March 2025 telephone calls, voicemail messages, the March 11, 2025 Biddeford DHHS interaction, and subsequent related correspondence through November 2026. Include the full PDF as a supporting source document.)

The central question is straightforward:

How can DHHS reasonably expect me to access a records-review process through an individual I have repeatedly and unsuccessfully attempted to reach, without providing another workable means of submitting the request?

I am not suggesting that every unanswered telephone call constitutes misconduct.

Government employees can be unavailable, and there may be circumstances I am not aware of.

But when an agency has been informed of a longstanding communication problem, simply providing the same contact information does not necessarily resolve it.

November 12: Another Visit to Sanford DHHS

On November 12, 2026, I went to the Sanford DHHS office in person.

I was attempting to follow the Department’s instructions and obtain assistance with the records-review procedure.

According to my account of the visit, the front desk employee informed me that she did not know whether Oliver was in the building or where he was located.

After consulting with OCFS staff, she directed me to call him and provided a telephone number.

I explained that I already had his number.

I explained that I had been attempting to reach him for an extended period without obtaining the assistance I was seeking.

And I explained that this was precisely why I had come to the office in person.

Ultimately, I left without speaking with Oliver or obtaining an appointment.

I cannot independently establish whether Oliver was present in the building that day, and I am not claiming that he personally refused to meet with me on November 12.

But the outcome is not disputed in my account: I did not obtain an appointment or a conversation with him.

Instead, I was once again instructed to call.

November 13: I Called Nathaniel Oliver Again

On November 13, 2026, I followed those instructions.

I called the number DHHS provided.

As I had anticipated, the call reached voicemail.

I left a detailed message identifying myself, the date, and FOAA #2159.

I explained that Levey had identified Oliver as the appropriate person to contact regarding the in-person review of records pertaining to me.

I explained that I had visited the Sanford office the previous day and had again been instructed to contact him.

I also documented my history of unsuccessful contact attempts dating back to February 2025.

Importantly, I did not demand access to records I might not legally be entitled to inspect.

I asked for clarification of the proper process, whether I was eligible to review records, and how to schedule an appointment if permitted.

I asked where a written and signed request should be submitted.

And I asked whether another authorized individual could assist if Oliver was unavailable or unable to help.

I requested a response within five business days or identification of another appropriate point of contact.

I recorded the call and the voicemail I left.

(November 13, 2026 recorded telephone call by Ryan Michaels to Nathaniel “Nate” Oliver at the number provided by Maine DHHS. The call reaches voicemail. Michaels identifies FOAA #2159, explains the Department’s November 12 referral and his in-person visit to the Sanford office, documents previous attempts to obtain assistance, and requests clarification, an authorized records-review appointment if eligible, or an alternative contact.)

As of publication on November 13, I have just left that message.

Oliver has not yet had the five business days I requested to respond.

It would be premature to characterize the absence of an immediate response as another refusal.

The importance of this recording is that it documents a further attempt to follow DHHS’s instructions in the context of the earlier documented history.

What happens next will be part of the continuing record.

DHHS Has Now Been Put on Written Notice

Also on November 13, I sent Levey a detailed written response.

I raised two distinct but connected concerns.

The first involved the Department’s handling of FOAA #1401 and FOAA #2159.

I pointed to the earlier $50,875 estimate, the approximately 15,282 potentially responsive emails, and the Department’s prior explanation that confidential records or portions would be identified during review.

I then asked why the Department had denied the later request on confidentiality grounds.

I also asked whether DHHS had determined that every potentially responsive record was confidential and, if not, how it intended to address records outside that restriction.

(First page of Ryan Michaels’s November 13, 2026 email to DHHS Public Access Officer Khristin Levey, documenting the apparent discrepancy between FOAA #1401 and #2159, identifying the $50,875 estimate, and requesting a specific explanation of the Department’s different responses.)

November 13, 2026 email from Ryan Michaels to Maine DHHS Public Access Officer Khristin Levey questioning the differing treatment of FOAA requests #1401 and #2159, including the $50,875 records estimate and documented difficulties contacting OCFS Program Administrator Nathaniel Oliver.

The second concern involved Oliver.

I documented my unsuccessful attempts to communicate with him, including the March 11, 2025 recorded interaction and my November 12, 2026 visit to Sanford.

I explained that the Department was directing me to the same person I had already spent considerable time attempting to reach.

I asked whether a written and signed request could be submitted through Levey’s office for documented delivery.

I also requested an alternative authorized contact or supervisory assistance.

My purpose was not to avoid the Department’s procedures.

It was to establish a way to follow them.

November 13, 2026 email from Ryan Michaels to Maine DHHS requesting an alternative authorized contact or supervisory assistance after repeated unsuccessful attempts to reach Nathaniel Oliver, the designated official for reviewing child protective records.

In closing, I emphasized that I was not seeking special treatment.

I was asking for a workable process.

I also attached my chronological record concerning Oliver so that the Department would have the documented history available when considering my concerns.

The Department now has my questions in writing.

It has been provided the history of my attempts to communicate with the designated administrator.

And it has been asked to identify a practical way for me to initiate the records-review procedure it described.

What Is the Public Supposed to Do?

There is a larger principle at issue here.

Government transparency is not simply about whether an agency has a policy or a designated official.

It is about whether the public can meaningfully use the procedures that exist.

Confidentiality protections are important.

Child protective records involve sensitive information, and the law appropriately places restrictions on disclosure.

But the existence of confidentiality protections does not eliminate the need for agencies to explain their decisions or administer available access procedures.

Likewise, a public official may have legitimate reasons for being unavailable.

But when someone has documented repeated unsuccessful attempts to reach that official, and the agency is made aware of those difficulties, the question becomes whether an alternative method of submitting the request or obtaining a decision is available.

I believe these are reasonable questions.

They are not demands for preferential treatment.

They are questions about whether the government is administering its own processes in a way that the people it serves can actually navigate.

And in this case, the Department’s own records make those questions especially difficult to dismiss.

Five Questions DHHS Should Answer

There are five questions I believe deserve clear, substantive responses.

First: Why did DHHS issue a $50,875 review-and-redaction estimate for FOAA #1401, then deny FOAA #2159, which sought materially the same underlying records, on confidentiality grounds?

Second: Has DHHS determined that every potentially responsive record is confidential under 22 M.R.S. §4008? If not, how does it distinguish confidential material from potentially releasable public records?

Third: What is the proper procedure for submitting a written and signed request to inspect records that I may legally be entitled to review?

Fourth: If Nathaniel Oliver is unavailable or unable to assist, who else is authorized to receive that request, determine eligibility, or arrange an appointment?

Fifth: Now that DHHS has received documentation of the longstanding difficulty I have encountered attempting to contact Oliver, what steps, if any, will it take to ensure that the available records-review procedure is meaningfully accessible?

These questions can be answered without disclosing confidential child protective information.

They concern the Department’s administrative decisions, its interpretation of the applicable procedures, and its ability to provide a workable point of contact.

This Is Not About Being Above the Rules

I am a father, a disabled veteran, and a journalist.

I have spent years attempting to understand decisions made by government agencies that have had profound consequences for my family.

That history is deeply personal.

But I do not believe the principles at stake here should depend on who is asking the questions.

Whether someone agrees with me, disagrees with me, supports my advocacy, or has never heard of The Maine Mirror, the underlying expectation should remain the same:

Government should be able to explain its decisions, identify the rules it is applying, and provide meaningful access to the procedures it tells people to follow.

I recognize that public employees have competing responsibilities.

I recognize that agencies must protect confidential information.

And I recognize that my requests do not automatically entitle me to every record in DHHS’s possession.

What I do not accept is the idea that asking for clarification should become an endless process of being redirected without obtaining a clear answer.

If the Department believes these two records requests are materially different, it can explain how.

If it believes every potentially responsive record is confidential, it can identify the legal basis for that determination.

If I am not eligible to inspect particular records, it can explain the applicable eligibility criteria and issue an appropriate determination.

And if the official designated to administer the process is unavailable, the Department can clarify whether another authorized person or documented submission method exists.

None of those requests requires anyone to be above the law.

They require the law and the Department’s procedures to be explained and administered.

What Happens Next?

As of November 13, 2026, I have submitted my written concerns to DHHS and left another voicemail for Nathaniel Oliver.

The Department has not yet had a reasonable opportunity to respond to those latest communications.

I will document any substantive response and update this reporting accordingly.

The Maine Mirror welcomes clarification from DHHS concerning its handling of FOAA #1401 and #2159, the applicable confidentiality restrictions, and the procedure for requesting an in-person review of eligible records.

Nathaniel Oliver is also welcome to clarify his role in that process and the appropriate method for requesting assistance.

The purpose of publishing these documents is not to declare that unanswered questions automatically prove misconduct.

It is to make the documented record available so readers can examine what happened and evaluate the questions for themselves.

Because after more than a year of attempting to obtain assistance, the issue is no longer simply whether I have asked.

The record establishes that I have.

The question now is whether the Department will provide a clear, substantive, and workable answer.

And that is where accountability begins.


Source Documents and Editorial Note

This article is supported by official DHHS correspondence concerning FOAA #1401 and #2159, the August 27, 2025 cost estimate and invoice, the October 3, 2025 clarification, the November 5, 2026 confidentiality denial, the November 12 identification of Nathaniel Oliver, the documented contact chronology, and the November 13, 2026 written follow-up.

The recorded November 13 telephone call is presented as evidence of the call and voicemail message left that day. It does not establish whether or when Oliver will respond.

The chronological record contains contemporaneous communications, later descriptions of recorded interactions, and references to related documentary evidence. Its contents should be evaluated according to the underlying sources.

The article does not allege that the existence of a confidentiality denial, a high processing estimate, or unanswered communications alone establishes unlawful conduct.

Identifying information concerning children and other sensitive personal information should be withheld from public exhibits where it is not necessary to understand the reporting.

The Maine Mirror will publish relevant updates if DHHS or Nathaniel Oliver provides additional information.


The Maine Mirror

Truth | Transparency | Accountability

TheMaineMirror.com


Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading