After being directed to pay $25 for police body-camera footage, a Berwick resident arrives ready to comply, only to encounter another unexpected obstacle.

Graphic about a Berwick FOAA payment roadblock, showing a $25 FOAA request for body camera footage, Berwick Town Hall, and confusion over payment requirements.

By Ryan Michaels | The Maine Mirror
November 10, 2026

BERWICK, MAINE — What should have been a routine $25 payment for public records became another frustrating experience at Berwick Town Hall on Tuesday, November 10.

On November 5, Attorney Matt Tarasevich, representing the Town of Berwick, responded to my October 29 Freedom of Access Act (FOAA) request for police body-camera footage.

His instructions were straightforward: submit $25 to the town, after which responsive records, to the extent they exist, were estimated to be available within two weeks.

Five days later, I arrived at Town Hall prepared to pay.

There was just one problem.

The employees I encountered appeared to have no idea what I was talking about.

After consulting a supervisor who did not come forward to speak with me, staff asked me to explain what I needed and began requesting details about my previously submitted FOAA requests.

But I wasn’t there to submit another request.

I wasn’t there to explain an existing one.

I was there to follow the instructions the town’s own attorney had already provided.

Another Unnecessary Obstacle

Following the encounter, I emailed Attorney Tarasevich documenting the unsuccessful payment attempt and requesting immediate corrective action.

My message emphasized that the town had already received, acknowledged, and assigned a fee to the request.

I asked the town to clarify how payment should be completed, ensure its employees received the necessary instructions, and confirm that the resulting delay would not be attributed to me.

One statement captured the concern:

“I cannot be expected to satisfy instructions that the town itself is unprepared to carry out.”

(November 10, 2026 email from Ryan Michaels to Attorney Matt Tarasevich formally documenting an unsuccessful attempt to pay the Town of Berwick’s $25 FOAA processing fee for October 29 police body-camera footage, citing apparent internal communication failures, unnecessary requests to repeat previously submitted information, and demands for immediate corrective action and written confirmation.)

The Bigger Question

This isn’t about $25.

It’s about whether a municipality has established a functioning process for fulfilling its obligations under Maine’s Freedom of Access Act.

The town’s internal communications have not been independently verified, and an administrative misunderstanding remains a possible explanation.

Nevertheless, when a government agency instructs someone to complete a particular step, its employees should be prepared to facilitate that step.

Residents should not be responsible for coordinating communications between municipal attorneys, administrators, and clerical staff.

As of November 10, I have formally requested clarification and corrective action. The Maine Mirror will report any substantive response from the town.

When government demands compliance from the public, the public has every right to expect government to be prepared to comply with its own instructions.


Editorial Disclosure: Ryan Michaels is the founder and editor-in-chief of The Maine Mirror and the individual directly involved in this incident. This article is based on his firsthand account and documented correspondence with the Town of Berwick’s attorney. The town has not yet provided its explanation of the November 10 encounter.

The Maine Mirror — Truth | Transparency | Accountability


Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading