By Ryan Michaels | The Maine Mirror
September 28, 2026

A vintage style balance scale with a $50 tag and a 'Waiver Denied' envelope on one side and a briefcase with a question mark on a notepad on the other side.

The Town of Berwick denied my request to waive a $50 public records fee. The answer came in a brief email from Paige Eggleston, an attorney at Bernstein Shur, who wrote that the town had asked her to respond on its behalf.

“The Town has denied your fee waiver request,” Eggleston wrote, instructing me to send $50 to the town clerk.

(Email from Bernstein Shur attorney Paige Eggleston stating that the Town of Berwick asked her to respond on its behalf, denying the $50 fee-waiver request and directing payment to the town clerk.)

Email correspondence from Paige Eggleston, Associate Attorney, informing the Editor about the denial of a fee waiver request and requesting payment of $50 to the Town Clerk.

I had explained that I am a disabled, unemployed veteran and described my financial circumstances. The town could consider the request and make its decision. What I cannot yet make sense of is its choice to have outside counsel deliver that decision.

Did involving an attorney cost the town more than the $50 it declined to waive?

I posted the email on Facebook with that question. Within minutes, commenters began asking essentially the same thing.

One wrote that the town had likely paid the attorney more than $50 just to send the response. Another replied that they had come to the comments to make the same point.

(Redacted Facebook exchange in which two commenters question whether the attorney’s involvement cost more than the $50 fee.)

Comment thread discussing feelings about an attorney's fees for sending a letter.

A different commenter estimated a substantially higher cost using an attorney rate they found online and an assumed amount of time. That calculation expresses the commenter’s concern; it does not establish the attorney’s rate, hours or bill for this matter.

(Redacted Facebook comment estimating the possible attorney cost, accompanied by a reaction image. The figures shown are the commenter’s unverified assumptions.)

Black and white image of a child in a striped outfit and a hat, peeking out of a window, with paper flying through the air.

Others reacted to the judgment behind the decision. “Common sense left the building long ago,” one wrote.

(Redacted Facebook comment questioning the common sense of the town’s approach.)

A comment displaying the text 'Common sense left the building long ago ...' along with options to like and reply.

Another called it “Idiocy at its best.”

(Redacted Facebook comment expressing frustration with the town’s decision.)

Social media post with a comment saying 'Idiocies at its best....' with a user profile silhouette.

Four comments posted shortly after one Facebook post are a snapshot of immediate reaction, not a survey of Berwick residents. Their shared concern, though, is straightforward: Why bring an outside attorney into a decision over $50, and what did that choice cost?

I have not seen an invoice, billing entry or town record showing what, if anything, the attorney charged for this particular response. The email establishes that the town asked the attorney to reply on its behalf. It does not establish the cost.

Maine’s Freedom of Access Act permits an agency to waive some or all public records fees when a requester is indigent or when release of the records meets the law’s public-interest standard. The law says an agency may grant a waiver; it does not make one automatic. Read the statute, 1 M.R.S. §408-A(11).

The question now extends beyond whether my $50 should have been waived. Could a town employee have communicated the decision? Was counsel asked to address a broader legal issue? Who authorized the attorney’s involvement, and was any time billed?

Berwick can answer those questions by explaining its decision and disclosing any associated expense. Until then, the public has the denial, the attorney’s email and a question that surfaced almost immediately: What did it cost to say no?


Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading