By Ryan Michaels | The Maine Mirror | September 24, 2026

Mirror Brief
Bottom Line Up Front: Earlier this month, The Maine Mirror documented an unusual sequence involving Berwick Police Chief and Maine House candidate Timothy Towne.
On August 31, I deliberately contacted Towne through his District 149 campaign email account. The subject identified the correspondence as “a question for you as a candidate.” The body went further: I expressly told Towne I was contacting him because he was seeking election to the Maine House.
Towne responded through that campaign account.
Days later, Berwick’s municipal attorney entered the correspondence and said he was writing “on behalf of the town of Berwick and Chief Towne.”
At the time, an important question remained unanswered:
How did correspondence deliberately initiated with Towne as a political candidate result in Berwick’s municipal attorney becoming involved?
There is now another public record.
On September 22, Towne filed his 42-Day Pre-General campaign-finance report with the Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election Practices.
The report covers July 15 through September 15, 2026—a period encompassing the entire August 31 through September 11 sequence documented by The Maine Mirror.
The filing reports $3,725.39 in expenditures.
It reports $0 in debts owed.
And nowhere among the listed expenditures does Towne’s campaign identify Bernstein Shur, attorney Matt Tarasevich, or another identifiable legal-services provider.
That does not establish, by itself, who paid for Tarasevich’s work or whether the work constituted a reportable campaign expenditure under Maine law.
But it establishes something narrower and important:
Towne’s campaign reported no identifiable legal expenditure or debt associated with the attorney’s involvement during the reporting period that included it.
Meanwhile, the attorney himself had already identified whom he represented:
“the town of Berwick and Chief Towne.”
Those two records now sit side by side.
And they sharpen a question The Maine Mirror has been asking since September 11:
Why did municipal legal representation enter correspondence expressly initiated with Towne as a candidate—and how was that legal work authorized and paid for?
The Campaign Filing Is Now Public
Towne’s September 22 filing is his 42-Day Pre-General Report.
Its reporting period is July 15 through September 15. The filing was due September 22 and was submitted that day at 5:41 p.m.
The filing contains another noteworthy detail.
Timothy Towne is identified as the filer. Timothy Towne is also identified as the campaign treasurer. And the report says it was submitted by Timothy Towne.
(Screenshot of Timothy Towne’s September 22, 2026 42-Day Pre-General campaign-finance filing. Highlighted fields show the July 15–September 15 reporting period, Towne as the filer and submitter, and Towne listed as his campaign’s treasurer. The treasurer email shown is towne4district149@gmail.com—the same campaign address used in the correspondence documented below.)

That matters because this is not simply a disclosure prepared by an unrelated treasurer.
As shown later in the filing, Towne personally certified the report.
But first, what does it actually disclose?
$3,725.39 in Expenditures. $0 in Debt.
The filing summary reports:
Total Expenditures: $3,725.39
Total Debts Owed: $0.00
Debt Balance: $0.00
(Filing summary from Timothy Towne’s September 22 campaign-finance report. The report lists $3,725.39 in total expenditures while reporting $0.00 in total debts owed and a $0.00 debt balance.)

The individual expenditures provide an even clearer picture.
The campaign reported eight expenditures during the period:
- Good Guys Signs — $837.90
- Amazon.com — $46.51
- United States Postal Service — $164.00
- Good Guys Signs — $607.00
- Amazon.com — $27.71
- Good Guys Signs — $94.65
- Anedot Inc. — $42.30
- Spectrum Marketing — $1,905.32
Total:
$3,725.39.
There is no listed payment to Bernstein Shur.
There is no listed payment to Matt Tarasevich.
And there is no other expenditure identified in the report as legal services.
(Complete expenditure table from Towne’s campaign-finance report showing eight reported expenditures totaling $3,725.39. The listed vendors are Good Guys Signs, Amazon.com, the U.S. Postal Service, Anedot Inc. and Spectrum Marketing; Bernstein Shur and Matt Tarasevich do not appear.)

The filing’s debt sections are equally direct.
No new debts to report.
No debt payments to report.
No open debts to report.
(Debt, loan and related sections of Towne’s September 22 filing. The report states “No new debts to report,” “No debt payments to report,” and “No debts to report” under open debts.)

That distinction matters.
Maine’s 2026 candidate guidance explains that campaign expenditures can include both paid expenses and unpaid obligations incurred for the purpose of influencing an election. An obligation incurred during one reporting period but remaining unpaid can be reportable as a debt.
That does not mean The Maine Mirror is concluding that Tarasevich’s work was legally a campaign expenditure. Whether a particular service falls within Maine’s campaign-finance definition depends on more than the email address through which correspondence occurred.
What the filing establishes is simpler:
Towne’s campaign disclosed neither a payment nor a debt identifiable as legal services associated with Tarasevich’s involvement.
Towne Personally Certified the Filing
The final certification removes another layer of uncertainty about who stood behind the disclosure.
It states:
“I, Timothy Towne, certify that the information contained in this report is true, accurate, and complete to the best of my knowledge.”
It identifies:
Certified By: Timothy Towne
Certified By Email: towne4district149@gmail.com
Certification Date: September 22, 2026, 5:41 p.m.
(Certification section of Towne’s September 22 campaign-finance filing. Towne certifies that the report is true, accurate and complete to the best of his knowledge. The certification identifies Timothy Towne and uses towne4district149@gmail.com.)

That email address is important.
It is the same campaign address at the center of the correspondence that preceded the Town Attorney’s involvement.
Now Go Back to August 31
The sequence begins with what I actually sent Towne.
On August 31, The Maine Mirror emailed:
The subject was:
“A documented Berwick issue and a question for you as a candidate”
The body made the capacity in which I was approaching Towne explicit:
“I’m also contacting you because you are now seeking election to the Maine House of Representatives.”
I explained why.
Rather than asking Towne a hypothetical campaign question about what he might do if a constituent brought him a documented government-accountability concern, I brought him an actual one.
The email then asked:
“Now that I have brought this matter directly to your attention, what, if anything, are you willing to do to help determine why it remains unresolved and whether the working record can finally be provided?”
(August 31 email from The Maine Mirror to Towne’s District 149 campaign address. The subject identifies it as “a question for you as a candidate,” while the highlighted body text expressly states that Towne was being contacted because he was seeking election to the Maine House.)

There is an important distinction here.
The underlying issue involved the Berwick Police Department.
But the question was deliberately presented to Towne as a candidate.
That was not something inferred afterward.
It was written into the subject line and body before Towne ever responded.
And Towne did respond.
Towne Answered Through the Campaign Account
On September 4, Towne responded from:
He addressed the underlying issue directly.
Towne wrote that another copy of the requested recording had been prepared and said:
“I believe that the Town of Berwick’s attorney has also notified you about the video being available for pick up at the police station.”
He signed the message:
Timothy Towne
( Towne’s September 4 response from towne4district149@gmail.com. Towne addressed the issue raised in the candidate inquiry, stated that another copy of the recording had been prepared, referenced the Town of Berwick’s attorney and signed the response “Timothy Towne.”)

So the documentary sequence to this point is straightforward:
Candidate inquiry.
Campaign email address.
Candidate capacity explicitly identified in writing.
Response from the campaign account.
Then the communication changed.
The Town Attorney Entered the Correspondence
After Towne’s September 4 response, I attempted to arrange a time to view the replacement recording, verify that it worked, and obtain it.
Those scheduling messages went unanswered by Towne.
On September 11, I followed up again.
Towne did not respond.
Instead, attorney Matt Tarasevich of Bernstein Shur did.
And Tarasevich identified exactly whose behalf he said he was acting on:
“I wrote on behalf of the town of Berwick and Chief Towne.”
Tarasevich then told me that Towne’s municipal email was the appropriate address for communications concerning Town matters and directed future communications accordingly.
(September 11 email from attorney Matt Tarasevich of Bernstein Shur. Tarasevich states, “I wrote on behalf of the town of Berwick and Chief Towne,” directs future Town-related communications to Towne’s municipal email address, and addresses access to the requested police recording.)

That sentence is central to this update.
The evidence does not require The Maine Mirror to infer that municipal counsel became involved.
Municipal counsel said so himself.
What remains unresolved is why, at whose direction, and under what financial arrangement.
So I Asked Towne Directly
On September 14, I returned to the original campaign email chain.
I explained exactly why.
I reminded Towne that my August 31 message had deliberately been sent to his District 149 campaign address, that its subject identified it as a question to him as a candidate, and that its body explicitly explained why I was approaching him in that capacity.
Then I asked the question directly:
“Did you request, authorize, ask for, or otherwise initiate the involvement of Berwick’s municipal attorney in responding to correspondence that I deliberately directed to you through your District 149 campaign email as a candidate for the Maine House?”
I told Towne that if the answer was yes, I wanted him to explain why he believed municipal counsel should become involved and whether he understood that the Town would incur an expense for that work.
If the answer was no, I asked him to say so and, if he knew, identify who made the decision.
(September 14 follow-up sent to Towne’s District 149 campaign account. The highlighted section documents why the original correspondence was deliberately directed to Towne as a candidate and asks whether Towne requested, authorized or otherwise initiated Berwick’s municipal attorney’s involvement.)

I also returned to the accountability question that began the correspondence:
“Looking back at that sequence now, is this how you believe a constituent who brings you a documented government-accountability concern should expect to be treated if you are elected to the Maine House?”
I explicitly directed that question to:
Timothy Towne, candidate for House District 149.
And I told him that if he declined to answer, I would report that without attempting to characterize his reasons.
(Continuation of the September 14 candidate follow-up. The email asks Towne whether the documented sequence reflects how a constituent bringing a government-accountability concern should expect to be treated if he is elected, and states that the question is directed to “Timothy Towne, candidate for House District 149.”)

As of publication, The Maine Mirror has not received Towne’s answer to those questions.
Two Records Now Have to Be Read Together
This is where the September 22 campaign filing materially advances the reporting.
On one side is the correspondence.
It establishes that:
I deliberately approached Towne through his campaign account.
I explicitly identified the communication as a question to him as a candidate.
Towne responded through that campaign account.
Berwick’s municipal attorney subsequently entered the matter and expressly said he was acting on behalf of “the town of Berwick and Chief Towne.”
On the other side is Towne’s campaign-finance disclosure.
It establishes that:
The reporting period encompasses the attorney’s September 11 involvement.
The campaign reported $3,725.39 in expenditures.
None of the disclosed expenditures identifies Bernstein Shur, Tarasevich or another identifiable legal-services provider.
The campaign reported $0 in debts.
Towne personally certified the report as true, accurate and complete to the best of his knowledge.
Those records do not establish that campaign-finance law was violated.
They do not establish that Tarasevich’s work legally constituted a campaign expenditure.
And they do not yet establish precisely how Bernstein Shur billed the work.
They do establish that the campaign reported no identifiable legal expenditure or debt for it, while the attorney expressly identified himself as acting for the Town and Chief Towne.
That is the documented record as it stands.
The Question Is No Longer Whether the Town Became Involved
It did.
The Town Attorney’s own email establishes that.
The unanswered question is why municipal legal representation entered this particular correspondence and how that representation was authorized and financed.
An attorney’s professional work does not become economically meaningless merely because there may not be an invoice containing a separate line item for one particular email.
Municipal counsel might be compensated hourly.
Counsel might work under a retainer.
Services might be bundled within a broader legal-services arrangement.
There may be some other billing structure.
Those possibilities affect how the cost is accounted for.
They do not change the documented fact that Berwick’s municipal attorney entered the correspondence and expressly identified himself as acting for the Town and Chief Towne.
And when that fact is placed beside the Town’s earlier handling of Towne’s dual-role proposal, the larger accountability question comes into focus.
Before the Attorney Emails, There Was the Dual-Role Decision
Timothy Towne is Berwick’s Police Chief.
Timothy Towne is also a Republican candidate for the Maine House.
Earlier this year, the Town of Berwick had to confront what those two roles would look like if Towne were elected.
And the public record shows that the proposal raised concerns.
An April 15 communication from Town Manager Arthur Capello documented what he had heard about the Select Board’s position:
“I will say, from the limited things I have heard, they feel you would be great, but they worry about you doing it while you are the police chief, given the time you would be out of town.”
The Board considered Towne’s proposal on May 5.
Two weeks later, on May 19, the Board voted unanimously to allow Towne to pursue legislative office while remaining Berwick Police Chief. (The Maine Mirror)
That progression created factual questions.
What additional information did the Board receive?
What resolved the concern about how much time Towne might spend away from Berwick?
How would Towne’s legislative schedule interact with his full-time municipal position?
What compensation arrangement had been approved?
What precisely did the May 19 vote authorize?
Was legal guidance obtained?
Those were among nine questions The Maine Mirror formally presented to Berwick.
The inquiry did not presume that the arrangement was unlawful.
It did not presume that the Board had acted improperly.
The purpose was straightforward:
Document what happened between the Board’s expressed concerns and its unanimous approval two weeks later.
Berwick Was Given the Opportunity to Explain
The Town had an opportunity to answer those nine questions.
It declined.
On September 21, Berwick responded through Town Attorney Matt Tarasevich.
Tarasevich wrote:
“The town of Berwick has asked that we respond on its behalf.”
He said the Town believed it had no legal obligation to answer the questions and stated that the Town therefore “declines to do so.”
No substantive answers to the nine questions were provided.
That does not prove wrongdoing.
It does not establish why the Town declined.
And a municipality’s decision not to answer a press inquiry does not, by itself, establish misconduct.
But it establishes something much narrower and verifiable:
Berwick was specifically asked to explain the public record surrounding its consideration and unanimous approval of Towne’s dual-role arrangement, and Berwick expressly declined to answer those questions.
That fact matters because of what happened in the other correspondence.
The Town Declined Questions About the Boundary—Then Entered It
The nine questions concerned the boundary between Towne’s municipal employment and his candidacy for another public office.
Berwick declined to answer them.
Yet when The Maine Mirror subsequently dealt directly with Towne through the campaign account—expressly and repeatedly identifying the communication as one directed to him as a candidate—Berwick did not remain outside that correspondence.
Its attorney entered it.
And he did so expressly:
“on behalf of the town of Berwick and Chief Towne.”
Towne’s campaign-finance filing now adds another piece.
The campaign disclosure covering the relevant period identifies no legal expenditure and no debt associated with an identifiable legal-services provider.
Again, that does not establish that the attorney’s services legally constituted a campaign expenditure.
It does not establish a campaign-finance violation.
And it does not yet tell us precisely how Bernstein Shur accounted for its work.
But the public record now allows the sequence itself to be examined.
Put the Entire Record Together
First:
Berwick officials had documented concerns about Towne simultaneously remaining Police Chief while potentially serving in the Maine Legislature.
Then:
Two weeks after the Select Board considered the matter, it voted unanimously to approve Towne’s proposed dual-role arrangement.
Then:
The Maine Mirror asked nine specific questions seeking to understand the transition from those concerns to unanimous approval.
Then:
Berwick responded through municipal counsel and expressly declined to answer those questions.
Then:
The Maine Mirror contacted Towne through his campaign email account, explicitly identifying the communication as one directed to him because he was a candidate for the Maine House.
Then:
Towne responded through that campaign account.
Then:
Berwick’s municipal attorney entered the correspondence and expressly stated that he was acting “on behalf of the town of Berwick and Chief Towne.”
And now:
Towne’s campaign-finance disclosure covering that period reports no identifiable legal expenditure and no debt associated with that representation.
Each fact is significant on its own.
Together, they produce a question the public record does not yet answer.
So Ask the Question
Did Berwick have concerns about Timothy Towne simultaneously campaigning for—and potentially serving in—the Maine Legislature while remaining Police Chief?
The public record shows that concerns existed.
Did the Select Board subsequently approve the arrangement unanimously?
Yes.
Did The Maine Mirror ask the Town nine specific questions seeking to understand what happened between those concerns and that unanimous approval?
Yes.
Did Berwick provide substantive answers?
No.
The Town responded through counsel and expressly declined.
Then The Maine Mirror approached Timothy Towne through the email account identified in his own campaign-finance filing as his treasurer email.
The subject explicitly said:
“a question for you as a candidate.”
The body explicitly told Towne:
“I’m also contacting you because you are now seeking election to the Maine House of Representatives.”
Towne responded from that campaign account.
And then Berwick’s municipal attorney stepped in.
Not Towne’s disclosed campaign attorney.
Not an attorney identified in Towne’s campaign-finance report.
Berwick’s Town Attorney.
And the attorney expressly said he was writing:
“on behalf of the town of Berwick and Chief Towne.”
Now Towne’s campaign-finance report covering that period is public.
No identifiable legal expenditure.
No legal debt.
$0 in total debts owed.
And Towne himself certified the filing as true, accurate and complete to the best of his knowledge.
So no accusation is necessary.
No motive needs to be assigned.
No campaign-finance violation needs to be alleged.
The records themselves bring us to the question.
Berwick expressed concerns about Timothy Towne’s proposed dual role.
Two weeks later, the Select Board unanimously approved it.
When asked nine questions seeking to understand the transition from those concerns to unanimous approval, Berwick expressly declined to answer.
And now Berwick’s own municipal attorney has stepped into correspondence explicitly initiated with Timothy Towne as a Republican candidate for the Maine House—while Towne’s campaign reports no identifiable legal expenditure or debt for that attorney’s involvement.
Which leaves a question that has become increasingly difficult to separate from the record:
Where does the Town of Berwick believe Timothy Towne the Police Chief ends—and Timothy Towne the political candidate begins?
And an even more specific one:
If Berwick will not explain how it determined those two roles could coexist, why did the Town then provide municipal legal representation in correspondence explicitly directed to Towne as a candidate?
That is not a conclusion about motive.
It is not a finding of illegality.
It is not an allegation of a campaign-finance violation.
It is a question created by Berwick’s own documented actions.
And, as of publication:
Berwick has not answered it.
Subscribe for free, below. Together we will obtain the Truth one record at a time.
Discover more from The Maine Mirror
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One Response