Editorial Standard BTM-003

An image featuring a workspace with a notebook, pen, and coffee mug displaying the words 'Truth. Transparency. Trust.' A stack of file folders labeled 'Accountability Includes Us' is visible alongside a magnifying glass, emphasizing themes of editorial accountability, corrections, and transparency.

Our Standards. Our Methods. Our Accountability.

Accountability cannot be something The Maine Mirror demands only from government agencies, elected officials, institutions, and other people in positions of public responsibility.

It has to apply to us, too.

That means readers should be able to understand who is responsible for what we publish, how we distinguish different kinds of editorial content, how we disclose relevant conflicts or involvement, how readers can challenge our reporting, and what happens when we get something wrong.

This standard establishes The Maine Mirror’s approach to editorial responsibility, transparency, corrections, clarifications, updates, reader challenges, conflicts of interest, disclosure, and accountability.

Our principle is simple:

If we expect others to show their work, acknowledge mistakes, answer questions, and correct the record, we must be willing to do the same.

Accountability includes us.


1. The Maine Mirror Will Be Transparent About Who Is Responsible

Readers should not have to investigate a publication to determine who is behind it.

The Maine Mirror is an independent publication.

Its editorial responsibility ultimately rests with the real people responsible for producing and publishing its work.

The Maine Mirror will clearly identify its founder, editor, contributors, or other relevant editorial personnel where appropriate.

We will not create fictional reporters, editors, contributors, photographers, interviewers, or other staff members and present them to readers as real people.

When artificial intelligence or synthetic media is used, those tools will not be presented as human staff members.

As established in BTM-001 — Artificial Intelligence & Editorial Transparency, AI may assist our work.

It does not receive a byline.

It does not become a reporter.

It does not assume responsibility for publication.

Human accountability remains human.


2. Editorial Responsibility Cannot Be Outsourced

The Maine Mirror may use software, artificial intelligence, transcription services, research tools, publishing platforms, outside expertise, public databases, contributors, and other resources.

Those tools and relationships can assist the editorial process.

They do not eliminate our responsibility for what ultimately appears under The Maine Mirror name.

If a tool produces an error and we publish it, responsibility rests with us.

If a source provides inaccurate information and we publish it without sufficient scrutiny, responsibility rests with us.

If we misread a document, misunderstand context, make an unsupported inference, or fail to disclose something readers reasonably needed to know, responsibility rests with us.

We cannot demand accountability from institutions while blaming our own mistakes on technology, sources, circumstances, or someone else.


3. Transparency Is More Than Disclosure

Transparency does not mean publishing every internal thought, private communication, confidential source, or unfinished piece of reporting.

It means giving readers the information they reasonably need to understand how our journalism was produced and how to evaluate it.

Depending on the circumstances, meaningful transparency may include:

Transparency should make journalism easier to evaluate.

It should not become a performance designed merely to create the appearance of accountability.


4. Reporting, Analysis, Commentary and Advocacy Should Be Identifiable

The Maine Mirror may publish several forms of editorial content.

Those forms can include:

These categories may sometimes overlap.

But readers should not be deliberately led to believe that opinion is straight reporting, that advocacy is detached analysis, or that inference is established fact.

Where the nature of the content would matter to a reasonable reader, The Maine Mirror should make that nature sufficiently clear.

Different editorial forms may involve different voices.

They do not receive different standards for factual accuracy.

Opinion may be forceful.

Advocacy may seek change.

Analysis may draw conclusions.

None of them receives permission to invent facts.


5. Personal Experience and Advocacy Must Be Disclosed When Material

The Maine Mirror recognizes that journalists and editors are human beings with experiences, relationships, interests, values, and histories.

Those experiences can contribute to meaningful journalism.

They can also create circumstances readers deserve to understand.

When The Maine Mirror, its editor, or a contributor has material personal involvement in the subject of a story, a significant advocacy role, a relevant financial interest, a close personal relationship, or another conflict that a reasonable reader would consider important when evaluating the reporting, that relationship should be disclosed when appropriate.

Disclosure should be specific enough to be meaningful.

It should not be used as a substitute for rigorous reporting.

A conflict does not automatically make reporting inaccurate.

A disclosure does not automatically make reporting reliable.

The evidence still matters.

As established in BTM-002 — Reporting, Sourcing & Verification, primary-source evidence remains the foundation of our factual conclusions.


6. Independence Does Not Require Pretending to Have No Perspective

The Maine Mirror does not believe credibility requires journalists to pretend they have no perspective, experiences, opinions, or values.

What matters is whether those perspectives improperly replace evidence.

Our reporting should not begin with a required conclusion and then search only for facts that support it.

We should remain willing to encounter evidence that complicates, weakens, or contradicts the understanding with which we began.

Editorial independence means maintaining the ability to follow the evidence even when the evidence is inconvenient.

It also means remaining willing to scrutinize people, institutions, organizations, or political interests regardless of whether we agree with them on other matters.

Evidence should not change weight because of who benefits from it.


7. Corrections Are a Responsibility, Not an Embarrassment

The Maine Mirror will make mistakes.

Every publication does.

Credibility is not built by pretending errors never happen.

It is built by what happens after an error is identified.

When credible evidence demonstrates that The Maine Mirror published a material factual error, we should correct it.

We should not leave an inaccurate statement in place merely because correcting it is uncomfortable, politically inconvenient, personally embarrassing, or damaging to an argument.

The correction should make the record more accurate.

That is the purpose.


8. What Counts as a Correction

A correction is appropriate when material factual information published by The Maine Mirror is demonstrated to be incorrect.

Examples may include:

Not every change to an article is a correction.

Minor typographical errors, formatting adjustments, grammatical improvements, or non-substantive edits may be fixed without a formal correction notice when they do not materially affect meaning.


9. Corrections Should Not Be Hidden

When an error materially affected the substance of an article, The Maine Mirror should not silently rewrite history.

The corrected information should be incorporated into the article.

A correction note should be added when appropriate so readers understand:

The goal is not to permanently shame ourselves for an error.

The goal is to preserve an honest record of what changed.

A transparent correction strengthens journalism more than a hidden mistake protects it.


10. Clarifications Are Different From Corrections

Sometimes an article may be factually accurate but still benefit from additional explanation.

A clarification may be appropriate when:

A clarification does not necessarily mean the original reporting was false.

It means we determined that readers would benefit from greater precision.


11. Updates Are Part of Continuing Reporting

News develops.

Records arrive after publication.

Public officials respond.

Court decisions are issued.

Meeting outcomes become known.

New documents surface.

People previously unavailable for comment may respond.

An article can therefore be accurate when published and later require an update because the underlying situation changed.

An update adds meaningful new information to an existing article.

Where the new information materially affects a reader’s understanding, The Maine Mirror should make the update clear.

Updating journalism is not the same as correcting an error.

It reflects that the story continued.


12. New Evidence Deserves Consideration

The Maine Mirror’s reporting reflects what the available evidence supports at a particular point in time.

New evidence may change that understanding.

If a reader, source, public official, subject of reporting, journalist, government agency, or other person provides credible new primary-source evidence that materially affects an article, The Maine Mirror should examine it.

We should not dismiss contrary evidence simply because it conflicts with our previous reporting.

Nor should we automatically accept it because someone describes it as exculpatory or decisive.

New evidence receives examination, not automatic acceptance or automatic rejection.

If the evidence materially changes what we can responsibly say, our journalism should change with it.


13. Readers May Challenge Our Reporting

The Maine Mirror invites good-faith challenges to factual reporting.

A reader who believes we got something wrong should be able to identify:

Whenever possible, challenges should include primary-source material.

This can include documents, recordings, correspondence, official records, photographs, data, or other evidence relevant to the disputed claim.

A challenge does not need to come from someone who agrees with The Maine Mirror.

Critics are entitled to be correct.

Evidence matters more than whether the person submitting it likes us.


14. Disagreement Is Not Automatically an Error

Not every disagreement requires a correction.

A person may disagree with:

Those disagreements may be legitimate and worth considering.

They do not automatically demonstrate factual error.

The Maine Mirror should distinguish between:

“I disagree with your conclusion”

and

“This factual statement is demonstrably false.”

Corrections address factual accuracy.

Reasonable disagreements over interpretation may instead warrant clarification, additional context, a response, or no editorial change at all.


15. Evidence Should Decide Correction Requests

A powerful person does not receive a correction merely because they demand one.

A government agency does not receive a correction merely because our reporting makes it uncomfortable.

A critic does not receive a correction merely because they object to the story.

Likewise, someone without power should not have a legitimate correction request ignored merely because they lack institutional influence.

The standard should be the same:

What does the evidence show?

When evidence demonstrates error, correct it.

When evidence does not establish error, we should not change accurate reporting merely to avoid criticism.


16. Requests for Comment and Corrections Are Different Processes

A request for comment generally occurs before publication.

A correction request occurs after publication.

They serve different purposes.

As established in BTM-002, requesting comment can help identify missing facts or context before an article is published.

A correction process examines whether something already published is materially inaccurate.

A person who did not respond before publication remains free to provide evidence afterward.

Their earlier silence does not prevent us from examining new information.

Likewise, a response submitted after publication does not automatically mean the original article was incorrect.

We should evaluate what the response actually establishes.


17. Subjects of Reporting Should Be Represented Accurately

The Maine Mirror may publish critical reporting.

Accountability journalism sometimes requires describing conduct that people or institutions would prefer not to see publicly examined.

Criticism does not eliminate our obligation to represent people’s positions accurately.

When a subject provides a substantive response, we should not deliberately distort it, strip it of necessary context, or describe it in a way that materially misrepresents what was communicated.

We are not required to reproduce every argument at unlimited length.

But when a response materially affects the substance of a story, it should be represented fairly.


18. The Maine Mirror Will Not Manufacture Participation

If someone does not respond, we should not imply that they did.

If someone declines to comment, we should not describe that as an admission.

If someone provides only a limited response, we should not portray it as though they answered questions they did not answer.

If someone never received a request because of a technical or delivery problem, that circumstance should not knowingly be described as refusal.

Accuracy applies to our own reporting process too.


19. AI Transparency Is Part of Editorial Accountability

As established in BTM-001, The Maine Mirror openly uses artificial intelligence.

Our use of AI should be sufficiently transparent for readers to understand its role.

AI may assist with research, document organization, transcription, drafting, editing, multimedia production, imagery, and other tasks.

It is not evidence by itself.

AI-generated article imagery is illustrative and is not presented as evidentiary proof.

Synthetic hosts or narrators should be identified when readers could reasonably mistake them for real participants.

And responsibility for material published by The Maine Mirror remains with human editorial decision-makers.

If AI contributes to a material factual error, the fact that AI caused or contributed to the mistake does not reduce our responsibility to correct it.


20. Changes to Editorial Standards Should Be Visible

The standards published through Behind the Mirror are intended to evolve.

Journalism changes.

Technology changes.

The Maine Mirror will learn from experience.

Readers will identify weaknesses.

New circumstances will raise questions we did not anticipate.

When an editorial standard materially changes, The Maine Mirror should update:

We should not pretend that today’s standards have always existed.

If we improve something, we can say so.

Growth is more credible when it is visible.


21. Standards Must Be Practiced, Not Merely Published

Publishing editorial standards accomplishes very little if we routinely ignore them.

Behind the Mirror is not intended to be decorative language.

The standards should influence actual editorial decisions.

When our conduct falls short of a published standard, the appropriate question is not:

How do we defend ourselves?

It is:

What happened, what should have happened, and what do we need to improve?

A standard does not guarantee perfection.

It creates something against which our actions can be measured.

That includes measurement by our readers.


22. Transparency About Growth

The Maine Mirror is an evolving independent publication.

Its systems, technology, editorial processes, and public standards will develop over time.

That growth may include improving:

We believe openly improving those practices is preferable to pretending they were perfect from the beginning.

A criticism can reveal a weakness.

A mistake can reveal a missing safeguard.

A reader can identify something we overlooked.

The appropriate response to a valid criticism is improvement.


23. Accountability Does Not Require Agreement

The Maine Mirror can listen to criticism without automatically agreeing with every criticism.

Good-faith accountability requires us to ask whether criticism is supported by facts and whether it identifies a meaningful weakness.

Sometimes the answer will be yes.

When it is, we should learn from it.

Sometimes criticism will involve subjective disagreement, incomplete information, political disagreement, or a characterization unsupported by evidence.

We are free to explain why we disagree.

The important distinction is that disagreement should come after examination, not instead of examination.

Listen first. Examine the evidence. Correct what is wrong. Improve what can be improved. Defend what remains supported by the facts.


24. Transparency Applies to Our Own Story

The Maine Mirror may sometimes become part of a story.

Other journalists may report on us.

Public officials may criticize us.

Readers may challenge us.

Our reporting may itself generate controversy.

When The Maine Mirror reports on circumstances in which it has become a participant rather than merely an observer, that involvement should be disclosed prominently enough for readers to understand it.

We should not use our own publication to erase material facts about our involvement.

We should distinguish:

Holding a mirror to ourselves is part of Behind the Mirror.


25. Corrections Should Preserve the Original Record When Appropriate

Digital publishing makes it easy to change an article without anyone knowing.

That ability should be used carefully.

When a material correction is made, The Maine Mirror should preserve enough information for readers to understand what changed.

That may be accomplished through a correction note, update note, revision history, or other appropriate disclosure.

We do not believe transparency requires preserving every typo forever.

But substantial factual changes deserve a visible record.


26. Removal of Published Content Should Be Uncommon

A factual correction does not ordinarily require deleting an entire article.

Where errors can be corrected, correction is generally preferable to disappearance.

There may be unusual circumstances where removal or substantial redaction is warranted, including:

When substantial content is removed after publication, transparency about the reason should be considered when legally and ethically appropriate.


27. Privacy Can Limit Transparency

Transparency is not absolute.

The Maine Mirror may possess information that should not be publicly disclosed.

Examples may include:

The existence of such information does not necessarily mean the underlying reporting should be abandoned.

It may mean that evidence must be redacted, summarized, withheld, or described carefully.

Showing our work does not require exposing people unnecessarily.


28. Funding, Relationships and Material Interests Should Not Be Hidden

Readers may reasonably want to know whether money, organizational relationships, sponsorships, partnerships, or other material interests could influence editorial work.

The Maine Mirror should disclose relevant financial or organizational relationships when they could reasonably affect a reader’s evaluation of particular reporting.

Sponsored or paid material should not be presented as independent reporting without disclosure.

Financial support should not purchase favorable factual conclusions.

Donors, advertisers, sponsors, partners, political organizations, advocacy groups, public officials, or other outside interests should not be permitted to dictate what The Maine Mirror reports as fact.

Editorial conclusions should remain accountable to evidence.


29. Readers Should Know How to Reach Us

Accountability requires a route back to the publication.

The Maine Mirror should maintain a reasonably accessible way for readers, sources, subjects of reporting, public officials, and other members of the community to:

Readers should not have to search endlessly for a way to contact us.

As The Maine Mirror’s systems develop, its public contact and correction mechanisms should remain accessible through the website.


30. Our Standards Apply Even When Nobody Is Watching

The easiest time to follow an editorial standard is when readers agree with us.

The meaningful test is when following the standard is inconvenient.

When evidence undermines a story we expected to publish.

When someone we strongly disagree with provides records showing we got something wrong.

When someone we respect is the subject of legitimate scrutiny.

When a correction is embarrassing.

When disclosure weakens an argument.

When fairness requires including context that complicates a compelling narrative.

Those are the moments when editorial standards matter most.

Accountability is not measured by what we say when the standard is easy. It is measured by what we do when the standard costs us something.


Behind the Mirror

The Maine Mirror exists in significant part because transparency and accountability matter.

We ask public institutions to answer difficult questions.

We examine records.

We challenge official narratives when the evidence warrants it.

We expect people entrusted with public responsibility to explain their decisions.

Those expectations would mean very little if we refused to accept them ourselves.

Readers should be able to ask The Maine Mirror:

Who is responsible for this?

What is your relationship to the story?

What happens if you are wrong?

Can I challenge your reporting?

Will you examine evidence that contradicts your conclusion?

Will you disclose a material correction?

Will you explain how your standards change?

Will you hold yourself to the same accountability you demand from others?

Our answer should be yes.

That is what Behind the Mirror is designed to make visible.

Our Standards. Our Methods. Our Accountability.


Our Accountability Standard, in One Sentence

Be transparent about who we are, disclose what readers reasonably need to know, examine criticism in good faith, correct material errors openly, change when better evidence requires it, and hold ourselves to the accountability we expect from everyone we cover.


Editorial Standard Information

Title: Editorial Accountability, Corrections & Transparency
Standard Number: BTM-003
Version: 1.0
Effective Date: August 2026
Series: Behind the Mirror — Editorial Standards
Applies To: The Maine Mirror editorial operations, reporting, investigations, analysis, commentary, advocacy-related content, multimedia, corrections, disclosures, and associated published material
Document Owner: The Maine Mirror
Status: Public Editorial Standard

Related Standards:
BTM-001 — Artificial Intelligence & Editorial Transparency
BTM-002 — Reporting, Sourcing & Verification

Review and Revision: This standard will be reviewed periodically and when experience, reader feedback, changes in journalistic practice, organizational growth, or The Maine Mirror’s own performance demonstrate that clarification or improvement is warranted. Material revisions will be reflected through an updated version number and effective date.


Behind the Mirror is The Maine Mirror’s public editorial standards initiative: Our Standards. Our Methods. Our Accountability.


Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Maine Mirror

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading